Andrew Rannells plays mayoral candidate in Deli Boys Season 2, premiering May 28 on Hulu

Show summary Hide summary

• 🔥 Quick Facts
• Andrew Rannells Brings Star Power to Hulu’s Dark Comedy
• Meet Your Season 2 Cast, From A-List Additions to Returning Favorites
• Season 2 Plot Promises Chaos, Money, and Mayhem on Philadelphia Streets
• Why Season 1 Became an Instant Classic and What To Expect This Time
• Will Andrew Rannells Help the Dar Brothers or Destroy Them

Andrew Rannells is trading Broadway stages for crime scheming in Deli Boys Season 2. The acclaimed actor plays ambitious Andrew Chadwater, a scheming district attorney eyeing the mayor’s office. All 6 episodes premiere May 28 on Hulu. Here’s everything fans need to know about the Hulu dark comedy’s highly anticipated return.

Andrew Rannells Brings Star Power to Hulu’s Dark Comedy

Andrew Rannells, best known for originating Elder Kevin Price in the blockbuster Broadway musical The Book of Mormon, joins the Deli Boys family as a recurring guest star. The Emmy-nominated performer brings his signature comedic timing to the role of Andrew Chadwater, a corrupt district attorney navigating Philadelphia’s criminal underworld.

Rannells’ character harbors big political dreams, plotting to use his prosecutorial power to land a major criminal bust and secure his path to the mayor’s office. His presence adds another layer of chaos to the Dar family’s already-complicated criminal schemes. The Broadway alum’s addition marks a major casting coup for the Onyx Collective series.

Meet Your Season 2 Cast, From A-List Additions to Returning Favorites

Deli Boys Season 2 assembles an impressive ensemble of comedy talent. Kumail Nanjiani recurs as Danyal, a defense attorney hired by money-laundering casino king Max Sugar, played by Fred Armisen. Lilly Singh joins as Aisha, while Robin Thede appears as Dr. Iverson. Tan France returns as the intimidating British crime mobster Zubair.

Core cast members Asif Ali, Saagar Shaikh, and Poorna Jagannathan reprise their roles as the Dar brothers and their gangster auntie. Creator Abdullah Saeed helms the series alongside showrunner Michelle Nader, with Jenni Konner developing the acclaimed crime comedy.

Season 2 Plot Promises Chaos, Money, and Mayhem on Philadelphia Streets

The Dar family is drowning in dirty cash from their criminal empire. Meanwhile, Philadelphia’s most dangerous crooks are circling like sharks, and a charismatic casino operator complicates everything further. Lucky Aunty develops a chaotic romantic entanglement, Raj plots elaborate revenge, and Mir tries expanding their criminal organization.

Season 2 Detail	Information
Release Date	May 28, 2026
Platform	Hulu, Hulu on Disney+
Episode Count	6 episodes (all release at once)
Creator	Abdullah Saeed

“When their convenience-store-magnate father dies, the family must navigate a criminal empire they never asked for while trying to keep their Philadelphia deli functioning as a front.”

— Series Premise from Hulu

Why Season 1 Became an Instant Classic and What To Expect This Time

Deli Boys Season 1 surprised critics and audiences alike when it dropped in March 2025. The dark comedy earned 96% on Rotten Tomatoes and developed a passionate fanbase. Viewers praised its blend of shocking twists, authentic character chemistry, and laugh-out-loud humor that balanced violence with genuinely funny moments.

The series’ success came from its willingness to subvert expectations. What starts as a family inheriting a convenience store quickly becomes a bloody, chaotic descent into Philadelphia’s criminal underworld. Season 2 promises to escalate the stakes significantly, introducing new antagonists while deepening family conflict.

Will Andrew Rannells Help the Dar Brothers or Destroy Them

Andrew Chadwater’s arrival represents a major threat to the Dar family operation. As an ambitious D.A. seeking a high-profile bust for his mayoral campaign, he’s actively hunting the very criminals the brothers are entangled with. This creates delicious tension between law and crime, corruption and ambition.

Rannells’ character could become either a dangerous antagonist forcing the family into survival mode or an unreliable ally temporarily exploitable for mutual benefit. Creator Abdullah Saeed has crafted a character whose motives remain deliberately murky, keeping audiences guessing throughout the season.