Show summary Hide summary
Nick Pasqual, the “How I Met Your Mother” actor, was found guilty of attempted murder on May 8, 2026. He attacked his estranged girlfriend with a knife, leaving her bleeding and barely clinging to life. Now he faces life in prison.
🔥 Quick Facts
- Verdict Date: May 8, 2026 in Los Angeles, California
- Charges: Attempted murder, first-degree residential burglary with person present, injuring a spouse or cohabitant
- Victim: Allie Shehorn, Hollywood makeup artist, stabbed multiple times
- Sentence: Maximum penalty is life in state prison, sentencing date TBA
“How I Met Your Mother” Star’s Shocking Conviction
Nick Pasqual appeared in multiple television shows, including roles on “How I Met Your Mother,” “Archive 81,” and was a producer on “National Day Riff.” Los Angeles jurors convicted him Friday after deliberations in a case that captivated Hollywood. The actor now faces a maximum sentence of life in state prison. He will be sentenced at a later date, with prosecutors pushing for the harshest penalty allowed under California law.
Pasqual’s television career made him recognizable to many. Yet his public persona masks a darker reality. The conviction marks a dramatic fall from entertainment industry acceptance. His next major moment comes during sentencing, when a judge determines his ultimate fate.
Nick Pasqual found guilty of attempted murder in stabbing at Sunland home
Christian Bale stars in The Bride!, Frankenstein reimagining now streaming on demand
The Brutal Attack Inside Sunland Home
On May 23, 2024, Pasqual broke into Allie Shehorn’s Sunland home and stabbed her more than 20 times. Shehorn, a talented makeup artist known for working on films like “Mean Girls” and “Rebel Moon,” was left fighting for her life with horrific injuries. A friend named Christine White discovered her bleeding out and immediately called for help. That quick action likely saved her life.
Shehorn spent over a week hospitalized following the brutal assault. Visible scars remain on her arms and throat. During trial testimony, she recounted the terrifying abuse she endured before the attack. The evidence painted a picture of escalating domestic violence.
Pattern of Abuse Leading to Tragedy
Prior to the stabbing, Shehorn had documented a disturbing pattern of violence. According to prosecution evidence, Pasqual hit her with a belt on January 29, 2024. Two months later, on March 6, he broke down multiple doors in their home. Allegations also include rape and choking on April 14. Shehorn wisely obtained a restraining order against him before the May stabbing.
| Date | Incident |
| January 29, 2024 | Hit with belt |
| March 6, 2024 | Broke down doors in home |
| April 14, 2024 | Rape and choking alleged |
| May 23, 2024 | Stabbed 20+ times in home |
The escalating violence was unmistakable. Shehorn took protective measures legal and personal. Yet Pasqual’s obsession and rage culminated in attempted murder.
“I locked the door and he just started punching holes in that door and broke that open, and I just ran into the bathroom because I thought there’s another lock on that door.”
— Allie Shehorn, victim, during court testimony
Flight to Texas and Extradition Back to Justice
After stabbing Shehorn repeatedly, Pasqual attempted to flee to Mexico. He was apprehended at the Fort Hancock International Bridge in Sierra Blanca, Texas, before crossing the border. Law enforcement quickly extradited him back to California to face charges. His failed escape attempt demonstrated consciousness of guilt and demonstrated premeditation.
The Los Angeles Police Department coordinated with Texas authorities seamlessly. Pasqual’s attempted flight strengthened prosecutors’ case considerably. Judges and jurors view such behavior as powerful evidence of awareness of wrongdoing. The swift capture and return to Los Angeles ensured the case reached trial without delay.
Will Pasqual Appeal or Accept His Sentence?
Pasqual faces a maximum sentence of life in state prison with no mention of parole eligibility yet. The conviction on all three counts provides prosecutors multiple avenues for demanding consecutive sentences. Shehorn expressed hope for true justice, telling reporters earlier that Pasqual cannot get away with his crimes. Her testimony proved devastating and credible, swaying jurors to a guilty verdict on every count presented. What comes next at sentencing will significantly impact her ability to move forward with her life and career recovery.
