Stolen Baby: Emily Osment stars in Netflix crime drama about Heidi Broussard murder

Show summary Hide summary

• 🔥 Quick Facts
• A Betrayal That Cost a Life
• The Deception Beneath Pregnancy Announcements
• Discovery and Investigation Timeline
• Emily Osment’s Portrayal and Production Details
• What Makes This Crime Case Significant in True Crime History
• How Does Netflix’s Adaptation Compare to the Original Events?
• Will Stolen Baby Reignite Public Conversation About Newborn Safety?
  • Sources

Emily Osment returns to dramatic storytelling in Stolen Baby: The Murder of Heidi Broussard, now streaming on Netflix following its April 17, 2026 release. The crime drama reconstructs one of the most unsettling cases involving a newborn theft and murder in recent American history—the true story of how a woman’s best friend became her killer.

A Betrayal That Cost a Life

On December 12, 2019, 33-year-old Heidi Broussard dropped her eldest child at school in Austin, Texas, with her newborn daughter Margot in tow. This ordinary morning became the last time she was seen alive. When Heidi failed to return home to her partner Shane Carey, police launched a desperate search for both mother and infant. Days turned into anguish as investigators retraced her final movements. The case took a grotesque turn when detectives focused on a neighbor’s account: Heidi had been spotted getting into a vehicle belonging to her long-distance best friend, Magen Fieramusca from Houston. What authorities uncovered defied the bonds of friendship itself.

The Deception Beneath Pregnancy Announcements

According to investigators, Magen had claimed she was pregnant at the same time as Heidi—a complete fabrication. The two friends shared ultrasound photos and pregnancy updates, building what Heidi believed to be a shared journey toward motherhood. In reality, Magen’s pregnancy was fake, part of a calculated scheme to acquire a newborn. When Heidi gave birth to Margot, Magen drove from Houston to Austin, ostensibly to support her friend during recovery. Instead, she strangled Heidi to death using a combination of a dog leash and her bare hands—a murder motivated by the singular desire to steal the infant and raise her as her own.

Discovery and Investigation Timeline

Event	Date	Details
Disappearance	December 12, 2019	Heidi Broussard and Margot vanish from Austin home
Body Located	December 19, 2019	Heidi found deceased in trunk of Fieramusca’s vehicle
Baby Recovered	December 19, 2019	Margot discovered unharmed at Fieramusca’s Houston residence
Arrest & Charges	January 2020	Capital murder, two counts of kidnapping, tampering with corpse
Guilty Plea	February 4, 2023	Fieramusca pleaded guilty to first-degree murder
Sentencing	February 4, 2023	55 years in prison on reduced charge

When investigators discovered Heidi’s body in the trunk of Magen’s vehicle, they also recovered baby Margot safe inside the Houston home. The child, miraculously unharmed despite her mother’s murder, was immediately reunited with her father and family. Police determined that Heidi had been murdered mere days after giving birth—killed by someone she trusted completely.

Emily Osment’s Portrayal and Production Details

“The two friends embark on their pregnancy journeys together, sharing updates and pics of their growing bellies. Magen’s so supportive that she even drives from Houston to Austin to be with Heidi when Heidi gives birth. But two weeks after Heidi’s baby is born, things take a dark turn.”

— Netflix Tudum description of Stolen Baby

Emily Osment, known for her television roles in The Kominsky Method and her longtime work in network television, takes on the chilling role of Magen Fieramusca. Anna Hopkins, recognized from The Expanse, portrays Heidi Broussard in this 1 hour 27 minute drama directed by Michelle Ouellet. The supporting cast includes Ian Lake as Cody, Jamie Spilchuk as Greg, and Paulino Nunes as FBI Agent Paul Richards. The film’s runtime allows for a detailed examination of both the investigative process and the psychological motivations underlying such an incomprehensible crime.

What Makes This Crime Case Significant in True Crime History

The Heidi Broussard murder case stands apart in contemporary true crime narratives because it demonstrates how obsession with motherhood can spiral into violence. Magen Fieramusca didn’t commit this crime in a moment of passion—instead, she meticulously constructed a false pregnancy over months, deceiving her closest friend to gain access to a newborn. The case reveals how abusers often exploit bonds of trust and intimacy, making it nearly impossible for victims to suspect danger from those closest to them. Furthermore, baby Margot’s survival represents a fortunate outcome in an otherwise tragic narrative. Had circumstances been even slightly different, the outcome for the infant could have been catastrophic.

The Texas criminal justice system’s handling of the case also demonstrates efficient investigation and prosecution. Fieramusca’s guilty plea in February 2023—roughly three years after the crime—allowed the legal process to conclude while sparing the victim’s family a trial. In exchange for her guilty plea to first-degree murder, prosecutors accepted a plea deal that removed the capital murder charge, sentencing her to 55 years in prison.

How Does Netflix’s Adaptation Compare to the Original Events?

The Netflix film adaptation arrives nearly seven years after the crime itself, yet the case remains under active public interest due to true crime documentary popularity. Director Michelle Ouellet had previously helmed The True Heroines, indicating experience with sensitive historical subject matter. The screenplay reportedly balances factual accuracy with dramatic storytelling, presenting the friendship’s formation, the fake pregnancy scheme, and the horrifying conclusion without sensationalizing the trauma. By casting Emily Osment—an actress with a background in dramatic television—the production signals intent to explore psychological complexity rather than exploit true suffering.

Netflix’s April 2026 release timing coincides with renewed interest in maternal crime cases and psychological thrillers across streaming platforms. The film’s availability on the world’s largest streaming service ensures that Heidi Broussard’s story reaches millions globally, cementing her case as a cautionary tale about verifying trust and remaining vigilant even with people we consider friends.

Will Stolen Baby Reignite Public Conversation About Newborn Safety?

Baby abduction cases remain statistically rare, yet they generate disproportionate public fear. The Margot case proved that law enforcement’s swift action and community awareness can save lives. The National Center for Missing Studies tracks such cases extensively, and the recovery of Margot Carey safely represents one of the successful outcomes that reinforces the value of rapid response. As Stolen Baby streams widely, conversations may emerge about hospital protocols for newborn protection, verification of visitors’ identities during postpartum period, and how genuine friends can sometimes harbor dangerous intentions despite outward displays of affection.

Sources

• Netflix Tudum – Official Stolen Baby cast, plot, and production details
• CNN – Coverage of Magen Fieramusca guilty plea and sentencing (February 4, 2023)
• A&E Network – In-depth analysis of case motivation and facts (August 12, 2025)
• Fox 7 Austin, KHOU 11 – Local news coverage of investigation and discovery
• IMDB – Cast, runtime, director, and production information