Show summary Hide summary
Stolen Baby: The Murder of Heidi Broussard just arrived on Netflix with Emily Osment delivering a chilling performance. This true crime drama recounts the shocking December 2019 case where an Austin mother and her newborn vanished. A sinister betrayal by her best friend shattered a community.
🔥 Quick Facts
- Netflix Release: Available now, May 15, 2026, rated TV-14
- True Crime Case: Heidi Broussard disappeared on December 12, 2019 with 2-week-old Margot
- The Killer: Best friend Magen Fieramusca strangled Heidi, faked her own pregnancy
- Sentence: Magen pleaded guilty and serves 55 years for first-degree murder
When Best Friends Hide Dark Secrets
The story begins with trust and pregnancy joy. Heidi Broussard, a churchgoing Austin woman, shares her joy with Magen Fieramusca, her childhood best friend living in Houston. When both announce pregnancies, their friendship deepens with shared updates and photos. Magen even boards a car to be present for Heidi’s delivery. But this elaborate performance masks something sinister underneath.
Magen’s pregnancy was entirely fabricated. She had been planning this betrayal for weeks with calculated precision. Her true intention was stealing Heidi’s newborn baby and raising the child as her own.
Stolen Baby: Murder of Heidi Broussard arrives on Netflix with Emily Osment, based on true 2019 crime
Alicja Szemplińska performs ‘Pray’ in Vienna for Poland’s Eurovision 2026 Grand Final
A Disappearance That Shocked a Nation
Just two weeks after Margot’s birth, tragedy strikes. Heidi and her baby vanish on December 12, 2019, after dropping off her eldest child at school. A neighbor witnesses Heidi getting into Magen’s car shortly before her disappearance, giving police their first lead.
What follows is a nationwide search effort. After one week, investigators make a horrifying discovery. Heidi’s body is found in Magen’s car trunk, evidence of strangulation evident. The villain in this real-life nightmare: cruel hands that took a loving mother from her children.
The Cast, Crew, and Production Details
| Detail | Information |
| Lead Actress | Emily Osment (as Magen Fieramusca) |
| Supporting Actress | Anna Hopkins (as Heidi Broussard) |
| Director | Michelle Ouellet |
| Runtime | 1 hour 27 minutes |
Emily Osment, known for The Kominsky Method, steps into the twisted role of Magen Fieramusca with unsettling authenticity. Anna Hopkins, from The Expanse, portrays Heidi with warmth and vulnerability. Director Michelle Ouellet crafts a harrowing true-crime drama that balances emotional depth with investigation detail.
“When Heidi Broussard is ready to give birth, her best friend Magen travels to Austin to be by her side. When Heidi and her newborn daughter go missing, suspicions about Magen’s true intentions are questioned.”
— Netflix, Official Description
The Real Investigation That Led to Justice
Law enforcement worked tirelessly to uncover Magen’s calculated deception. Heidi’s baby, Margot, was discovered alive and unharmed inside Magen’s Houston home, bringing relief to the desperate family searching for answers. The evidence of strangulation pointed directly to a heinous murder plot.
Magen Fieramusca was arrested and charged with kidnapping and tampering with a corpse. Later charges escalated to capital murder. In a stunning confession, she pleaded guilty to murder and now serves 55 years in prison for her crime. This case became a sobering reminder of how betrayal by trusted friends can destroy lives.
Should You Watch This Netflix True Crime Drama?
Stolen Baby deserves a place in your watchlist if you’re captivated by psychological thrillers grounded in real events. The film balances investigative detail with emotional impact, making viewers feel the weight of Heidi’s loss and Margot’s miraculous survival. Emily Osment’s performance as the villain is unsettling and brilliant.
The story raises profound questions about motherhood, betrayal, and justice. Available now on Netflix in one convenient sitting, viewers can experience 1 hour 27 minutes of gripping drama that illustrates how one person’s obsession can shatter multiple families forever.
Sources
- Netflix Tudum – Official production details and cast information for Stolen Baby
- CNN News – Coverage of Magen Fieramusca’s guilty plea and sentencing
- Austin Statesman – Austin mother Heidi Broussard murder investigation details
