Show summary Hide summary
Husband, Father, Killer brings a shocking true crime nightmare to screens, uncovering the disturbing story of Alyssa Pladl’s abusive journey. Based on a 2018 triple murder and suicide, this dark thriller exposes how manipulation, grooming, and incest led to tragedy.
🔥 Quick Facts
- Platform: Netflix and Lifetime, released March 18, 2026
- Stars: Jackie Cruz as Alyssa, Matthew MacCaull as Steven, Matreya Scarrwener as Katie
- Real Events: April 11-12, 2018 murders in North Carolina and Connecticut
- Director: Elisabeth Röhm, executive producer of the psychological thriller
When a Reunion Turns Tragic
In 1995, San Antonio teenager Alyssa Garcia met 20-year-old Steven Pladl online. Steven groomed the young girl over the internet before she ran away to New York. By age 17, Alyssa gave birth to their daughter Denise, who Steven physically abused by pinching her until she bruised and nearly suffocating her in a cooler. Alyssa made the heartbreaking decision to give the infant up for adoption.
Denise was renamed Katie and raised by adoptive parents Kelly and Anthony Fusco in Dover, New York. She grew up normally, graduated high school in 2016, and had no idea about her biological origins. In August 2016, Katie reached out to her birth parents on Facebook, desperate to know her roots. What seemed like a joyful reunion became a nightmare.
Sheryl Underwood defends Netflix Roast of Kevin Hart jokes about her late husband
NCIS season finale ‘Sons and Daughters’ airs tonight on CBS, resolves Vance storyline
The Grooming and Incest Spiral
Katie moved in with Steven and Alyssa while they were divorcing and living in separate bedrooms. Within months, Steven began grooming Katie, sleeping on her bedroom floor and escalating their contact into a sexual relationship. Alyssa discovered the abuse through their children’s journals, which revealed that Katie was pregnant with Steven’s child.
Despite being arrested for incest in January 2018, Steven made a shocking move: he married Katie in July 2017, lying on their marriage documents about their biological relationship. He fathered a son, Bennett, born September 2017. A Virginia court ordered Steven and Katie not to contact each other, but he violated the order multiple times after Katie ended their relationship.
Cast and Production Details
| Detail | Information |
| Release Date | March 18, 2026 (Netflix) |
| Lead Cast | Jackie Cruz, Matthew MacCaull, Matreya Scarrwener |
| Director | Elisabeth Röhm |
| Runtime | 1 hour 28 minutes |
The Horrific Ending and Aftermath
On April 11, 2018, Steven murdered his 7-month-old son Bennett by suffocating him and hiding his body in a closet. The following day, Steven tracked down Katie and her adoptive father Anthony as they drove through Connecticut. He opened fire with an AR-15 rifle, killing them both at a stop sign. Steven then called his mother to confess before turning the gun on himself in Dover, New York.
The case exposed systemic failures in the justice system. Despite Steven’s documented history of abuse toward the first child, the court released him on bond, and prosecutors argued nobody could have predicted his violent turn. Alyssa Pladl survived the tragedy and has largely withdrawn from public life, occasionally giving interviews about the dangers of incest and abuse.
Why This Story Demands Your Attention
Husband, Father, Killer exposes how grooming, manipulation, and system failures can devastate families in dark ways. The film asks critical questions about custody decisions, warning signs authorities missed, and how predators exploit family reunions. Elisabeth Röhm’s direction brings intensity to this true crime nightmare, while the ensemble cast delivers performances that capture the emotional weight of this tragic case. Will Netflix’s dramatization spark conversations about protecting vulnerable people from narcissistic abuse?
