Show summary Hide summary
Dan Levy’s newest Netflix comedy just shattered expectations. His latest series, Big Mistakes, debuted on April 9, 2026, and immediately claimed a near-perfect 95% Rotten Tomatoes score. This eight-episode crime comedy from the Schitt’s Creek creator pairs him with Rachel Sennott in a wildly chaotic tale of two siblings who stumble into organized crime.
🔥 Quick Facts
- Rotten Tomatoes Score: 95% from critics based on 19 reviews
- Release Date: All 8 episodes now streaming on Netflix since April 9
- Netflix Ranking: Debuted at #2 on Netflix’s Top 10 list
- Plot Summary: Two directionless siblings forced to work for gangsters become the most disorganized duo in organized crime
A Breakout Success From Day One For Schitt’s Creek Creator
Big Mistakes arrived at Netflix with enormous momentum. The 95% critic score places it among Netflix’s best-reviewed comedies in recent memory. Dan Levy serves as showrunner, executive producer, and lead actor, marking his most ambitious project since the Emmy-winning Schitt’s Creek ended in 2020. The collaboration with Rachel Sennott, creative force behind HBO’s I Love LA, blends dark humor with compelling character dynamics. Early viewership shows the series trending strongly at number two, just behind the popular Trust Me: The False Prophet documentary.
Two Siblings, One Criminal Conspiracy, Endless Comedy
The story centers on Nicky Dardano, played by Levy, an uptight pastor who gets pulled into crime. His sister Morgan, portrayed by rising star Taylor Ortega, joins him in this chaotic descent. Their mother Linda, played by Laurie Metcalf (Roseanne, Lady Bird), navigates family madness while launching a political campaign. Abby Quinn returns as Natalie, the third sibling. The ensemble cast creates genuine chemistry, making the premise feel fresh despite its familiar crime-comedy setup. Critics noted that Metcalf swings masterfully between steely authority and papery fragility, while Ortega brings hilarious unpredictability to every scene.
Schitt’s Creek creator’s Big Mistakes hits 95% on Rotten Tomatoes
Alan Jackson becomes grandpa again as daughter Ali welcomes baby girl Parker Anne
Why Critics Are Raving About This 95% Netflix Hit
The 95% Rotten Tomatoes score reflects solid critical consensus. Publications like Vulture praised how the show’s heightened and silly trappings create mostly a fun time. AV Club noted that Levy and Sennott’s sensibilities combine for a compelling blend of dark family comedy, crime caper, and character study. Reviewers across major outlets highlighted the cast as the show’s greatest strength. The series doesn’t take itself too seriously, instead embracing absurdist humor when two deeply incapable siblings attempt organized crime. It marks Netflix’s strongest comedy premiere in months.
| Release Detail | Information |
| Release Date | April 9, 2026 |
| Platform | Netflix |
| Episodes | 8 (all available now) |
| Rotten Tomatoes | 95% (19 critic reviews) |
“Even when it’s not being sweet, or when Nicky and Morgan are sincerely terrified about what’s happening to them, the trappings around them are so heightened and silly that Big Mistakes can’t help but come across as mostly a fun time.”
— Vulture, Television Review
Where They Filmed And How Critics Are Comparing It
Big Mistakes was filmed across New Jersey and Puerto Rico. Jersey City provided the fictional suburb of Glenview, while San Juan doubled as Miami for the cartel storyline. Visually, the series captures the chaos of suburban New Jersey colliding with organized crime. Some critics found the premise uneven, but audiences appear invested in the Dardano family’s mayhem. The show benefits from a cast that elevates mediocre moments with genuine performances. Levy’s charm remains his greatest asset, letting him balance both comedy and vulnerability in serious scenes.
Will Big Mistakes Return For Season Two On Netflix?
Netflix comedies rarely run as one-season-only productions, suggesting renewal prospects look strong. The series was not marketed as a miniseries, indicating the creators planned for potential continuation. Eight episodes proved enough to establish characters and plot threads that could expand further. With 95% critical approval and solid debut rankings, Netflix will likely order a second season if viewing metrics support the critical reception. Dan Levy has proven formula, and pairing him with Rachel Sennott’s writing instincts creates a winning combination worth extending. Fans eager for more dysfunctional Dardano chaos should expect good news within weeks.
Sources
- Forbes – Coverage of Big Mistakes 95% Rotten Tomatoes score and critical reception
- Netflix Tudum – Official details on cast, release date, and production information
- Rotten Tomatoes – Critic score verification and review aggregation
