Reeve Carney makes Broadway debut as Gatsby opposite wife Eva Noblezada

Show summary Hide summary

• 🔥 Quick Facts
• Theater’s Golden Couple Takes Center Stage
• Director Calls It ‘A Delicious Pairing’
• Celebrating Their Shared Musical Journey
  • Watch: “My Green Light: Unplugged” Performance
• What Comes Next for the Broadway Power Couple?
  • Sources

Reeve Carney made his stunning Broadway debut as Jay Gatsby yesterday, stepping into the iconic role opposite his real-life wife Eva Noblezada. The married couple took their first bows together at the Broadway Theatre, marking a historic moment for the musical that won the 2024 Tony for Best Costume Design. This marks the first time they’ve performed together as husband and wife on Broadway’s biggest stage.

Theater’s Golden Couple Takes Center Stage

Reeve Carney and Eva Noblezada have spent years building their bond on stage. They originated the roles of Orpheus and Eurydice in Hadestown on Broadway and in London’s West End. Most recently, they starred together in Cabaret in London, with Carney as the Emcee and Noblezada as Sally Bowles.

Now, as a married couple, they bring a new level of chemistry to F. Scott Fitzgerald’s tragic Jazz Age romance. Noblezada, a two-time Tony nominee, originated the role of Daisy and has become synonymous with the character.

Director Calls It ‘A Delicious Pairing’

Director Marc Bruni expressed enthusiasm about the unconventional casting. He praising Carney’s unique interpretation of Gatsby. Bruni admired Carney’s work in Hadestown and Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark.

Detail	Information
Venue	Broadway Theatre in New York City
Composer	Jason Howland and Nathan Tysen
Book Writer	Kait Kerrigan
Director	Marc Bruni

“I’m a huge fan of Reeve from Hadestown and from Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark. When the idea came up to have them together, it just seemed like a delicious pairing. Carney has a great sense of hope that marries with Jay Gatsby.”

— Marc Bruni, Director

Celebrating Their Shared Musical Journey

The couple has built their relationship through Broadway collaborations. From Hadestown‘s ancient Greek mythology to Cabaret‘s decadent Berlin, they’ve mastered dramatic storytelling together. Now, The Great Gatsby gives them a chance to explore Jazz Age glamour and heartbreak.

Noblezada originally created the role of Daisy, and Carney brings fresh energy to Gatsby‘s obsessive pursuit. Their chemistry on stage reflects years of trust, both as performers and as partners in life.

What Comes Next for the Broadway Power Couple?

The success of Carney’s debut opens doors for future collaborations. The Great Gatsby musical continues to draw audiences with its Tony Award-winning production design and emotional depth. Will other Broadway shows recognize the magic this couple brings to the stage?

For now, Reeve Carney and Eva Noblezada are focused on delivering unforgettable performances as Gatsby and Daisy. Their love story, both on and off stage, reminds audiences why Broadway remains a place where dreams come alive.

Sources

• Playbill – “My Green Light: Unplugged” acoustic cover featuring the couple
• Broadway Across America – Director Marc Bruni discusses the casting as ‘a delicious pairing’
• Just Jared – First bow photos and coverage from March 31, 2026