Saturday Night Live performers ranked as fans vote for all-time favorite

Choosing the greatest performer in the history of Saturday Night Live is more than a matter of taste — it’s a window into how comedy, politics and popular culture have changed over five decades. As the show continues to influence what people quote, meme and stream, asking “who’s the best?” helps us name the performers who shaped those moments.

The conversation matters now because SNL’s back-catalogue is easier than ever to watch and share, and a new generation discovers sketches alongside long-time fans. Picking a favorite reveals what you value — sharp political satire, unforgettable characters, musical impressions, or sheer versatility.

How to think about “best”

There’s no single metric that crowns one comedian as the ultimate SNL star. Consider a mix of factors: cultural reach, range of characters, memorable catchphrases, influence beyond the show, and the ability to land live sketches under pressure.

Writers' notes and cue cards on a table illustrating criteria for judging comedy
How to compare cultural impact, versatility and longevity when judging SNL performers.

  • Cultural impact — Did their characters enter everyday conversation?
  • Versatility — Could they switch between impressions, characters and sketches?
  • Longevity — Did they leave an enduring mark on the program and comedy more broadly?
  • Innovation — Did they change what was possible on live sketch TV?

Notable SNL performers to consider

Below is a selection of widely celebrated cast members from different eras. This list is not a definitive ranking but a cross-section to spark comparison.

Montage of vintage TV set and sketch props representing SNL eras
Notable SNL performers from different decades shaped the show’s evolving voice.

Performer Era Signature work Why they matter
John Belushi 1970s Samurai sketches, “Chippendales” dance Explosive physical energy that defined early SNL’s anarchic tone
Gilda Radner 1970s Roseanne Rosannadanna, character work Pioneering female voice in sketch comedy with deeply human characters
Eddie Murphy 1980s Mr. Robinson, Buckwheat Revitalized the show with star power and pop-culture dominance
Phil Hartman 1980s–1990s Impressions, “Unfrozen Caveman Lawyer” Reliable versatility and razor-sharp impersonations
Mike Myers 1990s Wayne, Dieter Created enduring characters that translated to major films
Julia Louis-Dreyfus 1980s Sketch ensemble work Early example of television comedy talent who later achieved broad acclaim
Dana Carvey 1980s–1990s Church Lady, President Bush impressions Master of physicality and spot-on political mimicry
Will Ferrell 1990s–2000s Celebrity impressions, “More Cowbell” Broad, big-idea comedy that became part of mainstream jokes
Tina Fey 2000s Sarah Palin impression, writing leadership Showrunner-caliber influence and reshaped political satire on SNL
Amy Poehler 2000s Weekend Update, character work Sharp timing and later a trailblazer for women in comedy leadership
Kristen Wiig 2000s–2010s Target Lady, Penelope Inventive, oddball characters with strong emotional undercurrents
Kate McKinnon 2010s–2020s Political impressions, eccentric characters Versatile mimic who pushed boundaries in both satire and character comedy

Each performer above altered the show’s language in a different way. Some brought viral moments, others shifted the program’s editorial voice, and a few launched major film and television careers.

What this means for viewers

Picking a favorite is not just nostalgia; it affects what sketches get clipped, what performers are rewatched, and which episodes are curated on streaming platforms. That, in turn, shapes public memory of the program’s best years.

If you’re choosing right now, think about the types of comedy that land with you: do you prefer satirical precision, character-driven sketches, or raw live energy? Your answer will point you to different eras and names.

Share your pick

There’s no single correct answer — only different ways a performer can mean a lot to audiences. If you have a favorite, note who they are and why: a short explanation helps others see a new side of a familiar sketch. Your choice says as much about changing comedy tastes as it does about SNL’s long-running cultural presence.

Give your feedback

Be the first to rate this post
or leave a detailed review



Art Threat is an independent media. Support us by adding us to your Google News favorites:

Post a comment

Publish a comment