Sam Bateman’s wives still won’t leave him, Netflix doc reveals

Show summary Hide summary

• 🔥 Quick Facts
• The Documentary That Exposed a Hidden Crisis
• Control From Behind Bars Still Holds Women Captive
• Three Women Who Found Freedom From the Prophet
• Why All Underage Victims Escaped But Adults Remain Trapped
• What Questions Remain About the Aftermath?
  • Sources

Sam Bateman is locked away serving a 50-year prison sentence, yet the Netflix documentary reveals a chilling reality: many of his wives still won’t leave him. Despite his incarceration, he maintains unsettling control through daily prison phone calls, reinforcing his grip on followers who believe he is God’s prophet.

The Documentary That Exposed a Hidden Crisis

Netflix’s “Trust Me: The False Prophet” premiered on March 18, 2026, unveiling the true story of how a cult psychology expert and her videographer husband infiltrated an FLDS breakaway sect to expose systematic abuse. Director Rachel Dretzin chronicles Samuel Bateman’s rise to power following the 2011 conviction of FLDS leader Warren Jeffs. Bateman quickly proclaimed himself the new prophet and began accumulating up to 20 wives simultaneously, nearly half of them minors as young as 9 years old. Christine Marie and her husband Tolga Katas moved to Short Creek, Utah in 2016, secretly gathering evidence while Bateman believed they were documenting his message.

The four-part miniseries features explosive footage where Bateman admits to crimes on hidden audio while coaching his child victims in real time. The documentary builds toward his 2022 arrest and orchestration of a shocking kidnapping plot where eight minors vanished from state custody as he directed operations from prison.

Control From Behind Bars Still Holds Women Captive

The most disturbing revelation emerges post-release: Bateman has not lost power. According to Christine Marie, prison guards allow him to make many daily calls, essentially functioning as an IV line of indoctrination for his followers. The women receive constant reinforcement of his spiritual authority, being told he speaks directly with God and that his imprisonment makes him a martyred prophet. Christine states the phenomenon bluntly: “That communication with him is like an IV of indoctrination. It’s like they’re getting fed certainty right into their veins.”

The situation presents a psychological paradox: imprisonment strengthened his hold rather than weakening it. Director Dretzin explains that “the vast majority of the adults featured in this film are still followers of Sam Bateman to this day.” Only three women broke free: Julia Johnson, Moretta Johnson, and Nomz Bistline.

Three Women Who Found Freedom From the Prophet

Survivor	Status and Breakthrough
Julia Johnson	Confronted her husband, testified against Bateman, now free. Her courage inspired the entire investigation.
Moretta Johnson	One year in prison “set me free,” she said. Now married with a family, fully separated from the sect.
Nomz Bistline	Prison triggered independent thinking. Now pursuing music career, publicly speaking about her FLDS nightmare.

Julia Johnson, the mother who risked everything, became the documentary’s heroine. She defied her own husband to protect her children from Bateman’s abuse, ultimately leading authorities to his compound. Moretta Johnson, her daughter and one of Bateman’s wives, spent a year in prison that paradoxically liberated her mind. She credits incarceration with forcing her to “start thinking for myself.” Nomz Bistline, perhaps the most vocal survivor, has emerged as a public advocate, working with vocal coaches and producers while healing through music.

“Prison was the best and worst thing that happened to me. It forced me to start thinking for myself. It forced me to start questioning things.”

— Nomz Bistline, Survivor and Advocate

Why All Underage Victims Escaped But Adults Remain Trapped

The documentary reveals a devastating irony: all nine underage victims eventually testified against Bateman, breaking free from his control. However, most adult wives remain trapped in psychological bondage. The critical difference was physical separation. When authorities placed Bateman’s child brides in separate foster homes following the November 2022 kidnapping attempt, they finally gained perspective beyond his influence. Dretzin explains: “Once they had the perspective of being outside of the group, they were able to see what had happened to them and speak out.” The adults, still embedded in the FLDS community, lack this transformative distance from Bateman’s control systems.

For the adult women to mentally escape requires severing contact with Bateman entirely. Christine Marie proposes the solution: restricting his prison phone access would break the psychological cycle. Without daily reinforcement of his supposed divine authority, she believes followers could finally ask themselves the critical question: “Maybe he did make all this up so that he could get money, power, and sex like every other cult leader.”

What Questions Remain About the Aftermath?

The documentary ends with troubling uncertainty. Despite Bateman’s conviction, his male most devoted followers are also serving lengthy sentences (including 25-year and life sentences), yet the cult structure persists. How long will Bateman’s wives wait for a prophet imprisoned for decades? Will Short Creek’s insular community ever fully reject his influence? Most pressingly, can Netflix’s documentation create enough external pressure to convince corrections officials to limit his communication privileges? The documentary raises these haunting questions because one brutal truth remains: in the year since his sentencing, most of his wives have not left him.

Sources

• Netflix Tudum – Official coverage of Trust Me: The False Prophet documentary and survivor interviews, April 2026.
• Biography.com – Samuel Bateman wives documentation and FLDS cult leader analysis.
• Fox News – Breaking coverage of cult leader exposure and investigation outcomes.