Paul Rudd warned Steve Carell against The Office audition

Show summary Hide summary

• 🔥 Quick Facts
• The Moment Paul Rudd Nearly Cost Steve Carell a Career
• Everyone Was Against The Office Before It Started
• Why Steve Carell Ignored the Worst Advice
• The Show That Became a Cultural Phenomenon
• Has Paul Rudd Come Around on His Office Prediction Now?
  • Sources

Paul Rudd gave Steve Carell one of the worst career tips ever. The Ant-Man star told Carell not to audition for The Office. Speaking on Amy Poehler’s podcast this week, Carell revealed how his costar tried to stop him from pursuing the iconic role.

The Moment Paul Rudd Nearly Cost Steve Carell a Career

Steve Carell was mulling over the Michael Scott audition for The Office when Paul Rudd pulled him aside on the Anchorman set. According to Carell, Rudd was blunt and discouraging about the entire project. “Rudd pulled me aside and was like, ‘Don’t do it, man. Don’t audition,'” Carell recalled to Poehler.

Rudd wasn’t subtle about his skepticism. Carell described the warning as fierce, saying he was told to not “touch this with a 10-foot pole.” The hesitation made sense at the time. Ricky Gervais’s British Office was iconic and beloved. The idea of an American adaptation seemed doomed to Rudd and many others in Hollywood.

Everyone Was Against The Office Before It Started

Carell and Poehler laughed at how universal the rejection was. “This is a terrible idea,” Poehler remembered thinking when she first heard about the American Office remake. “No one can be as good as Ricky Gervais, no one can do that show.” The skepticism was real and widespread across the entertainment industry.

Carell revealed that the NBC pilot tested terribly with audiences. “Our pilot was the lowest testing pilot in the history of NBC,” he stated. “People really hated it. They actively hated it. And I don’t quite know how it got legs after that.” The show barely survived its first season before finding its footing and becoming one of television’s greatest comedies.

Why Steve Carell Ignored the Worst Advice

Show Detail	Information
Character	Michael Scott, Regional Manager
Run Dates	2005-2013 (9 seasons)
Emmy Nominations	6 nominations for Carell
Initial Reception	Lowest-tested NBC pilot ever

Carell made the decision to ignore Rudd’s advice, and it paid off spectacularly. Despite everyone’s doubts, he committed to the role. Carell even remained protective of his performance by avoiding Gervais’s original U.K. Office. “I watched a minute of one and he was so good and so specific and so funny, I thought, ‘If I watch a second more, I’m just gonna go on an audition with that,'” he explained to Poehler.

“Rudd pulled me aside and was like, ‘Don’t do it, man. Don’t audition.’ It was like, ‘There is no way.'”

— Steve Carell, on Amy Poehler’s Good Hang podcast

The Show That Became a Cultural Phenomenon

The Office defied all expectations and became a juggernaut for NBC. What started as an experiment in American mockumentary comedy evolved into iconic television. Carell’s performance as Michael Scott became legendary, defining the character across nine seasons. Emmy voters recognized his work with six nominations, cementing his place in comedy history.

The show’s legacy only grew after it ended. Through streaming platforms like Peacock, The Office reached new generations of viewers who discovered Carell’s brilliant comedic timing. The spinoff series The Paper recently launched its second season, proving the universe Carell helped create remains vibrant and engaging. If Carell had listened to Rudd that day on the Anchorman set, television history would have been drastically different.

Has Paul Rudd Come Around on His Office Prediction Now?

Carell didn’t address whether he’s had a follow-up conversation with Rudd about his disastrous prediction. The two actors have worked together multiple times since Anchorman and clearly maintain a friendship despite Rudd’s early skepticism. Carell seemed amused by the entire situation when recounting it on Poehler’s podcast, treating it as a humorous anecdote rather than a grudge.

This moment reminds entertainers and audiences alike that even the smartest predictions can be wildly off-base. Rudd based his analysis on the strength of Gervais’s original Office, assuming lightning couldn’t strike twice. Instead, Carell’s bold choice to pursue the role created something entirely new. His Michael Scott became just as iconic as David Brent, proving there’s always room for fresh interpretations in television.

Sources

• Entertainment Weekly – Coverage of Steve Carell’s Good Hang podcast appearance discussing Paul Rudd’s warning.
• People Magazine – Interview details from March 24, 2026, podcast episode with Amy Poehler.
• The Independent – Report on the Marvel star’s initial doubts about The Office remake.