Show summary Hide summary
Shelia Eddy’s story unfolds in Hulu’s Friends Like These documentary that just dropped March 6, 2026. The three-part docuseries reveals the chilling murder investigation into 16-year-old Skylar Neese. Eddy and her accomplice confessed to a crime that shocked their entire community.
🔥 Quick Facts
- Release Date: March 6, 2026 on Hulu and Disney+
- Documentary Format: Three-part true crime series examining the 2012 murder case
- Key Subjects: Shelia Eddy and Rachel Shoaf, both sentenced to prison for stabbing Skylar Neese over 50 times
- Parole Eligibility: Both killers eligible for parole in May 2028
A Friendship That Started at Age 8
Skylar Neese and Shelia Eddy met as children and remained inseparable for years. The two West Virginia teenagers went from best friends to accomplices in one of the state’s most shocking crimes. By their sophomore year at University High School, tensions within their friend group began to emerge. Shelia and Rachel Shoaf grew closer, leaving Skylar increasingly isolated. Social media posts revealed the brewing conflict between the three girls during 2012.
Director Clair Titley approaches the documentary from an “inside-out” perspective. Rather than focusing solely on police investigation, the series explores Skylar’s world through her own eyes and her peers’ experiences. The documentary uses archival footage, Twitter posts, and police records to build a timeline of events leading to the tragedy.
Shelia Eddy’s story unfolds in Hulu’s Friends Like These doc debut
Dhurandhar 2 trailer drops today, Ranveer Singh’s revenge saga heating up
The Night Everything Changed
On July 5, 2012, Skylar returned home late from her Wendy’s shift. That evening, she sneaked out of her bedroom window to go for a late-night drive with Shelia and Rachel. What began as a night out with friends ended in a dark wooded area near the Pennsylvania border. According to Rachel Shoaf’s confession, the two girls had planned the attack before the drive began.
Skylar asked only one question when the assault began. As Shoaf and Eddy counted to three and attacked from behind with kitchen knives, the 16-year-old victim managed to ask why. The girls stabbed their friend over 50 times before dragging her body into the woods. They left Skylar’s remains concealed beneath branches and debris in a remote location.
Digital Evidence Builds the Case
| Investigation Element | Key Discovery |
| Phone Records | Both phones pinged in Blacksville, WV at 4 a.m. on murder night |
| Surveillance Footage | Shelia’s car captured at Sheetz gas station near crime scene |
| Physical Evidence | Skylar’s DNA found on blood in Shelia’s car trunk |
| Confession Timeline | Rachel confessed January 3, 2013, about 6 months after murder |
Investigators discovered inconsistencies in the girls’ stories almost immediately. When detectives retraced their stated route, Shelia and Rachel gave conflicting directions at key intersections. The similarity between their written statements suggested the girls had rehearsed their alibi. As days turned to weeks, phone records and surveillance cameras confirmed they had lied about their whereabouts on the night Skylar vanished.
“They asked Rachel, ‘Why did you guys kill Skylar?’ And her only answer to that was, ‘We just didn’t like her.'”
— State Police Corp. Ronnie Gaskin, West Virginia State Police
Sentences and Parole Projections
Rachel Shoaf pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and received 30 years in prison with parole eligibility after 10 years. At her 2023 parole hearing, she revealed that she and Shelia were in a romantic relationship and feared exposure. That confession, combined with ongoing remorse, did not sway the parole board. Shelia Eddy pleaded guilty to first-degree murder and was sentenced to life imprisonment with mercy, allowing parole eligibility after 15 years.
Both are currently incarcerated at Lakin Correctional Center in West Virginia. According to court records, both killers will become eligible for parole in May 2028. Skylar’s father, Dave Neese, has been vocal about his opposition to their release. The family successfully advocated for “Skylar’s Law” in 2013, requiring immediate Amber Alerts when children are reported missing in West Virginia.
How Does Hulu’s Documentary Change Our Understanding?
The streaming docuseries captures something traditional crime documentaries often miss: the world of teenage girls in 2012, particularly through social media. Director Titley embedded viewers in Skylar’s digital life by integrating tweets and posts into the visual storytelling. You see her Facebook messages, Twitter conflicts, and the hidden layer of teenage communication that fueled the tragedy. The documentary challenges viewers to confront uncomfortable questions about friendship, jealousy, and how quickly bonds can turn deadly.
Hulu’s approach emphasizes that this wasn’t a random act by outsiders but a calculated betrayal from those closest to Skylar. The series examines the pressures of growing up in the digital age and demonstrates how online conflicts can escalate into real-world violence. Streaming on Hulu and Disney+, this three-part investigative drama serves as both true crime entertainment and a cautionary tale about the fragility of teenage friendships.
Watch: Friends Like These Official Trailer
Sources
- Time Magazine – Comprehensive breakdown of the investigation and confession details from court records
- Biography.com – Complete case timeline including victim background and sentencing information
- People Magazine – Reporting on the docuseries debut and killer interviews at parole hearings
