Show summary Hide summary
Paul Anthony Kelly just revealed the emotional weight of portraying JFK Jr. in FX’s breakout series Love Story. The newcomer Canadian actor reflects on landing his first major role just 3 weeks before filming began. His honest interview sheds light on the struggle to capture one of America’s most beloved icons.
🔥 Quick Facts
- Casting Crisis: Production was 3 weeks from shutting down when Paul Anthony Kelly was discovered
- Last-Minute Discovery: Kelly, born October 1988, found through screen tests after hundreds of actors auditioned
- Premiere Date: Love Story debuted on February 12, 2026 on FX and Hulu
- First Role: This is Kelly’s first major acting role, making the pressure incredibly significant
The Impossible Casting Challenge
Finding the right actor to play JFK Jr. nearly derailed the entire production. Executive producer Brad Simpson revealed they had seen virtually every male actor between 25 and 38 years old. Creator Connor Hines became so desperate he was approaching strangers at the gym, asking if they would audition. The team needed that specific 1980s old-school masculinity, that Richard Gere or Tom Selleck vibe that modern Hollywood seemed unable to deliver.
Simpson admitted they were about to pause production entirely. Then Ryan Murphy suggested they go back and review all the self-tapes they’d already received. From that pile, they pulled 13 new candidates for fresh screen tests. That’s when everything changed.
Love Story’s Paul Anthony Kelly reveals weight of portraying JFK Jr.
Sam Levinson pays tribute to Eric Dane, ‘I’m heartbroken’
An Unexpected Breakout Star Emerges
During the screen test, Paul Anthony Kelly walked in and immediately impressed everyone. A hair and makeup team member whispered to Simpson, ‘You’re crazy if you don’t cast him’. The chemistry was instant. He had the physicality, the likeness, and that intangible star quality that felt like JFK Jr. himself had walked into the audition room.
Kelly, 37, wasn’t even on their radar initially. He was a model transitioning into acting, not the obvious choice. Yet somehow, he captured exactly what they’d been searching for through countless auditions. The timing was perfect, the pressure was immense, and this unknown Canadian actor became the face of one of America’s most iconic figures.
The Weight of Portraying an American Icon
| Aspect | Detail |
| Role | John F. Kennedy Jr. |
| Series | Love Story (FX, Hulu) |
| Co-Star | Sarah Pidgeon as Carolyn Bessette |
| First Major Role | Yes, career-defining opportunity |
| Preparation | Listened to JFK Jr.’s narration daily |
Kelly described the emotional toll to The Hollywood Reporter. Stepping into JFK Jr.’s shoes required immense care and integrity. He spent time imagining what happened behind closed doors in their most intimate moments. The goal was truth, not spectacle. Kelly acknowledged that JFK Jr. was a beloved figure, and he wanted to do right by his memory.
“Stepping into the characterization of John F. Kennedy Jr. definitely has a lot of weight to it. Because of that, the care and integrity that I had to bring — to find the truth in the whole story — was essential.”
— Paul Anthony Kelly, Actor
Finding JFK Jr.’s True Essence
What surprised Kelly most was discovering JFK Jr.’s deep desire for normalcy. Despite his famous name and royal status among American royalty, he wanted to live like an everyman. He got along with everybody and made everyone feel special. This wasn’t a prince seeking privilege, but a man determined to forge his own path on his own terms.
Kelly prepared by listening to JFK Jr.’s narration of his father’s speeches every single day. He studied interviews and documentaries. The research was meticulous because the stakes were personal. Love Story climbed to number 1 on Disney+ in its opening week, giving this unknown actor sudden international visibility and responsibility.
What’s the real story behind Love Story’s internet obsession?
Paul Anthony Kelly has become an overnight sensation since Love Story premiered on February 12, 2026. The internet has been fascinated by his resemblance to JFK Jr., his chemistry with Sarah Pidgeon, and the raw emotion he brings to critical scenes. He filmed one of the most heartbreaking moments early on, sitting with Naomi Watts’ Jackie Kennedy as she dies from non-Hodgkin lymphoma.
This is only the beginning for Kelly. From nearly losing his role due to a casting crisis to becoming a major television star, his journey mirrors the real-life drama that audiences are devouring. The series explores not just romance but tragedy, loss, and the cost of living in the public eye.
Sources
- The Hollywood Reporter – Paul Anthony Kelly discusses portraying JFK Jr. and filming his final moments
- People Magazine – Exclusive casting story about Paul Anthony Kelly’s last-minute discovery
- FX Networks – Official Love Story series information and release dates
