Show summary Hide summary
Judge Greg Mathis shocked fans last night when he was unmasked as 14 Karat Carrot on The Masked Singer. The 65-year-old daytime TV legend took everyone by surprise during Star Trek Night on March 18. His final performance of “Shining Star” landed him in the bottom, leading to the emotional reveal.
🔥 Quick Facts
- Celebrity revealed: Judge Greg Mathis, legendary courtroom TV host with decades on the bench
- Costume: A golden vegetable with scales of justice on the fanny pack and Motown vibes
- Judge who guessed: Robin Thicke correctly identified Mathis after his ironic judge clue
- Episode date: March 18, 2026, Season 14, Episode 10 on FOX
The Iconic Reveal That Stunned Panelists
Greg Mathis performed “Shining Star” by Earth, Wind & Fire during the double elimination episode. His smooth vocals and powerful delivery earned crowd applause, but not enough to keep him safe from elimination. When his name was called and the mask came off, panelists couldn’t believe their eyes. Ken Jeong had guessed Steve Harvey, Jenny McCarthy thought it was legendary soul singer Al Green, and Rita Ora was convinced it was Craig Robinson. Only Robin Thicke cracked the code.
Mathis had teased the judges with brilliant clues throughout the episode. A gigantic judge’s gavel appeared on stage, and he delivered the punchline: “It’s ironic being on this side of a panel of judges when I’m usually the one doing the judging.” That single sentence gave Thicke the confirmation he needed, cementing his legendary status among panelists.
Judge Greg Mathis unmasked on The Masked Singer as 14 Karat Carrot
Michael J Fox makes rare appearance at 2026 Actor Awards, receives standing ovation
A Career Spanning Five Decades of Justice
Judge Greg Mathis is best known for his long-running courtroom series Judge Mathis, which aired for two decades and earned him Emmy awards and international recognition. The Detroit native created a unique blend of justice and compassion, dealing with small claims cases while imparting life lessons. His energy matched perfectly with 14 Karat Carrot’s golden, vibrant stage presence.
Beyond the courtroom, Mathis has been an inspirational figure, overcoming a troubled youth to become one of America’s most beloved TV judges. His appearance on The Masked Singer shows his willingness to embrace new challenges and entertain audiences in creative ways.
From Motown Clues to Star Trek Night Performance
| Detail | Information |
| Song 1 | “Hold On, I’m Comin” by Sam & Dave |
| Song 2 | “Tainted Love” by Gloria Jones |
| Final Song | “Shining Star” by Earth, Wind & Fire |
| Clues Provided | Judge’s gavel, scales of justice, Motown landscaping van |
14 Karat Carrot’s costume design was pure genius. The gold vegetable costume featured scales of justice embroidered on the fanny pack, a judge’s gavel, and references to Motown music. The clues pointed directly to Mathis’ iconic career, yet the panel (except for Thicke) remained in the dark. Johnny Gill appeared in a video clue saying Mathis had been “like a brother” to him for years.
“It’s ironic being on this side of a panel of judges, when I’m usually the one doing the judging.”
— Judge Greg Mathis, 14 Karat Carrot unmasking
The Double Elimination and Season 14 Drama
March 18, 2026 will go down as one of The Masked Singer’s most memorable nights. Not only did Greg Mathis get eliminated as 14 Karat Carrot, but Evan Ross (son of Diana Ross) was unmasked as Stingray in the same episode. Both stars gave powerful final performances before facing elimination. Ross performed “Starboy” by The Weeknd, while Mathis delivered his soul-filled rendition of “Shining Star.”
Season 14 of The Masked Singer has been filled with surprises, featuring 18 masked contestants who have collectively sold 94 million records. The remaining competitors include Pangolin, Galaxy Girl, Cat Witch, Pugcasso, and Crane, all competing for the final trophy.
Will Judge Greg Return to the Courtroom or Explore More Entertainment Ventures?
Now that Judge Mathis has taken his talents to The Masked Singer stage, fans are wondering what’s next for the legendary television personality. Will he continue hosting his courtroom show, pursue more singing opportunities, or focus on his family? Mathis Family Matters, his digital series, has also kept him in the public eye.
His appearance on The Masked Singer proved he’s not afraid to reinvent himself and challenge audiences with new talent. At 65 years old, Mathis continues to show the energy and passion that made him a household name across multiple generations. The Masked Singer gave him a platform to express another side of his personality, and America got to see a beloved judge step outside his comfort zone.
Sources
- Variety – The Masked Singer Season 14 Episode 10 reveal details and performance breakdown
- E! News – Judge Greg Mathis unmasking during Star Trek Night double elimination
- The Sun – 14 Karat Carrot identity clues and Judge Mathis confirmation
